Supplement guide

How to Submit a Supplement to Progressive

Here is how to compare your estimate to Progressive’s, how to write a supplement, and what to send.

Checked November 2026.

How to submit a supplement to Progressive, step by step

If you are a Progressive network shop:

  1. Tear down and photograph. Find the hidden damage early (within 48 hours of the vehicle arriving) and photograph it before anything is repaired. Write your estimate in your system.
  2. Line up the two estimates. Match every line of Progressive’s Mitchell estimate to your CCC estimate and list what they cut, changed or left off. This is the slow part; Reclaimr does it in minutes.
  3. Give a reason for every line. Say what changed and why it belongs on the repair. Cite the vehicle maker’s repair information or the estimating system’s guidelines where you can.
  4. Tell Progressive in WebTracker. Enter a “Supplement Request” event, no later than 48 hours after “At Shop,” with the reason in the notes. Send the documents: the itemized supplement, photos and invoices, in the format your representative asks for.

If Progressive sends a supplement back:

  1. Check Progressive’s supplement. Progressive writes the supplement itself, so line its revised estimate up against yours again to see what’s still missing. If it still comes up short, send a written rebuttal.

If you are not in Progressive’s network

Progressive’s estimates carry one instruction: “To ensure proper and prompt payment for additional damage discovered during the course of repairs, contact Progressive for supplement handling procedures.” Start with the representative named on the estimate, and send an itemized supplement with the reason for each line, photos of the damage and any invoices.

Progressive’s estimates also say it “honors the prevailing labor market rate in your area.” If your posted rate is higher, expect the rate to come up, and have your posted rates ready.

Why Progressive supplements take so long

“If it’s a $10,000 hit, it could take an hour to match.”

Beth Wilson, owner, Thurston’s Plus Autobody, in FenderBender

Most shops write their estimates in CCC ONE. Progressive usually writes in Mitchell: in our customers’ cases over the past year, 87% of Progressive estimates were written in Mitchell.

Before you can respond to the supplement, you need to understand the differences between what you wrote and what they wrote, and the two systems describe the same repair differently. Here’s an example:

Your CCC estimateProgressive’s Mitchell estimateWhat’s different
LT Rear door w’strip
R&I · 0.3 hr
L Rear Door Weatherstrip
Remove/Install · 0.2 hr
Different words for the same work, and 0.1 hour cut
Upper absorber
Repl · $63.52
Frt Bumper Impact Absorber
Remove/Replace · $63.52
Same part and price, different name
Vehicle pre-scan
Subl · $150.00
PRE SCAN
Additional Labor · $150.00
A sublet on one, labor on the other
Aim headlamps
0.5 hr
Headlamps
Check/Adjust · 0.4 hr
Different order, and 0.1 hour cut
Post-repair scan
Subl · $150.00
Not on their estimateLeft off

Why comparing estimates is so difficult:

  • Different estimating systems use different words for the same work.
    The workCCC saysMitchell says
    Take a part off and put it back onR&IRemove/Install
    Take a part off and replace it with a new oneReplRemove/Replace
  • Each estimate has a different line order. Progressive’s line 22 can be your line 42, so every call with the adjuster starts with “which line?”
  • Different estimating systems have different paint math. CCC calculates paint supplies from the refinish hours; Mitchell prints one paint and materials line. Compare them as one total per estimate, not line by line.
  • Each system has its own guide to what a labor time includes. Mitchell has P-pages and CCC has the MOTOR guide, so an operation one estimate lists on its own can be folded into a labor time on the other.

How Reclaimr helps

Your CCC estimate and their Mitchell estimate, lined up in minutes.

Add both estimates. Reclaimr pairs every line by the repair it describes, across estimating systems, and gives you one list of everything Progressive cut or changed, with a note on each line saying why.

1

The same repair, written two ways

Your estimate says one thing, Progressive’s says another.

Yours: LT Rear door w’strip · R&I
Theirs: L Rear Door Weatherstrip · Remove/Install

1

Lines paired by what they are

Not by how they’re spelled. When Reclaimr isn’t sure, it asks you to confirm.

2

A different line order

Their line 22 is your line 42.

2

Both line numbers on every row

Their line on top, yours underneath, the difference on the right. The adjuster finds each one in seconds.

3

Paint supplies figured differently

CCC charges supplies by the refinish hour; Mitchell prints one materials line.

3

Compared as one total per estimate

So the gap you send is a real difference, not a quirk of the format.

4

A reason for every line

The rep needs to know why each line belongs on the repair.

4

Notes written for you

Written for you: what changed and why. Edit any of them before it goes.

5

The 48-hour clock

The car sits until the request is reviewed.

5

Ready in minutes, in one PDF

Download the Supplement Overview, with your photos and invoices if you want them.

Any estimating systemWorks with all of the leading estimate formats
About 30 lineson a typical Supplement Overview, every one paired for you
Rebuttal includedIf Progressive still says no, a line-by-line rebuttal comes from the same lines

Typical means the median of the latest Supplement Overview on 151 customer cases, 11 Aug to 9 Nov 2026. Actual results vary by shop and carrier.

What the adjuster opens

Your wording and Progressive’s, on one page.

Their line on top in their words, yours underneath in yours, the difference on the right, and a note that says what changed and why.

Matched lines with dollar differences

SourceLineOperDescriptionPriceLaborReq.
InsuranceIns.#18OverhaulFront bumper—3.1+$79.30
Shop#4O/HFrt bumper assy—4.4
Shop note · Our estimate replaces the front bumper cover (shop line 3). Overhauling takes the bumper assembly off the car and apart, so the new part can be fitted and the rest moved over to it. Sensors, lamps and brackets have to sit exactly where the maker put them; one fitted loose or out of position can make park assist warn falsely, aim a lamp wrong or leave the cover gapped.
Repair lines missing from insurance estimate
Shop#2—Pre-wash vehicle—0.5+$30.50
Shop note · Dirt hides damage and gets ground into the repair. We need to clean the vehicle to keep grit out of the work.
Sample rows. Line numbers and amounts are illustrative.

Questions shops ask

Where do I submit a supplement to Progressive?

Network shops enter a “Supplement Request” event in WebTracker. Other shops follow the instruction on Progressive’s estimate: contact Progressive for supplement handling procedures, starting with the representative named on the estimate.

How fast do I have to request a supplement from Progressive?

Progressive’s network guide says as soon as possible and no later than 48 hours after the vehicle is marked “At Shop,” with the reason in the notes. Tear-down to find hidden damage is allowed within 48 hours of arrival.

Does Progressive write estimates in Mitchell or CCC?

Usually Mitchell. In our customers’ cases from December 2025 to November 2026, 87 of 100 Progressive estimates (87%) were written in Mitchell and 12 in CCC.

Will Progressive reinspect the vehicle?

It may. Progressive’s guide says a representative may reinspect the vehicle promptly after you report the damage, and then you agree on the additional work and the supplement.

Who writes the supplement on a Progressive claim?

For network shops, Progressive’s guide says Progressive writes all supplements. Your final charges are the estimate plus the supplements Progressive approves in writing, so check its supplement against your estimate before you agree.

Can Reclaimr compare a Mitchell estimate with a CCC estimate?

Yes. Upload both estimates and Reclaimr pairs the lines across the two systems, asks you to confirm when it isn’t sure, and builds a Supplement Overview PDF with the notes written for you.

Bring your next Progressive estimate.

Bring your estimate and the Progressive estimate that came back. We’ll line them up with you on the call.

Rather just talk it through? (443) 952-4052